The Maharashtra government has withdrawn its petition before the Bombay High Court challenging the Centre and the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) over the distribution of food safety inspection and enforcement powers.
The development took place on November 21, when the state's request to withdraw the petition was presented before a division bench headed by Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna. The court accepted the request and disposed of the matter as withdrawn.
Editorial Insight
Key Highlights
Important points readers should notice.
Issue/Event: Maharashtra withdraws its legal challenge against the Centre and FSSAI over food safety enforcement powers.
Location: India.
Authority/Organisation: Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration, FSSAI and Bombay High Court.
Action Taken: The state sought withdrawal of its petition, and the Bombay High Court accepted the request on November 21.
Impact: The legal challenge has ended without a judicial ruling on the underlying Centre-State dispute over food safety inspection powers.
The petition had been filed by Maharashtra's Food and Drug Administration (FDA), through State Food Safety Commissioner Tukaram Mundhe, in September 2026. It challenged provisions and regulatory arrangements under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, which the state claimed had reduced the authority of its food safety officers.
At the centre of the dispute was the inspection of food businesses holding central licences. Maharashtra argued that the 2006 Act envisaged a decentralised enforcement framework in which state food safety commissioners and their officers played a significant role in inspections and enforcement.
However, the state alleged that arrangements introduced by FSSAI had created a parallel central enforcement structure. Its petition questioned the establishment and functioning of positions such as Central Food Safety Officer and Central Licensing Authority.
Editorial Analysis
Why This Matters
Consumer Protection: Food safety inspections help identify unsafe products, hygiene violations and risks to public health. Effective enforcement is essential for protecting consumers. Centre-State Coordination: The case highlighted questions about how central and state authorities should coordinate inspections of food businesses holding central licences. Business Compliance: Restaurants, food manufacturers, hotels and other food businesses need clear information about which authority can inspect their premises and enforce applicable standards. Regulatory Accountability: The dispute raised questions about the legal framework governing central licensing and state-level enforcement responsibilities. Administrative Transparency: The absence of a publicly recorded specific reason for withdrawal makes further clarification about the government's decision important.
The state also challenged an FSSAI directive dated May 12, 2023, which restricted state food safety officers from independently enforcing provisions of the Act at food businesses holding central licences, subject to the applicable arrangements and exceptions.
Maharashtra had sought judicial intervention to challenge the relevant regulations and directions, arguing that they interfered with the enforcement responsibilities of state authorities.
The withdrawal came after the state government reversed its earlier decision to pursue the litigation. According to reporting by The Indian Express, government communications directing the withdrawal did not record a specific reason. Commissioner Tukaram Mundhe told the newspaper that the decision had been taken as per a government directive.
A senior state official cited in the same report said the issue concerned the procedure for resolving disputes between the Centre and states, rather than a judicial determination of the underlying regulatory questions. Another report by The Times of India had earlier indicated that discussions with FSSAI were being considered to resolve the concerns outside court.
The withdrawal does not mean that the Bombay High Court ruled in favour of either the Maharashtra government or FSSAI. The court disposed of the petition after accepting the state's request to withdraw it; it did not decide the substantive dispute.
The development is significant because food safety regulation involves inspections, sampling, licensing and enforcement action against businesses that may violate prescribed standards. Clear coordination between central and state authorities is important for ensuring consistent monitoring and protecting consumers.
The next question is whether the concerns raised by Maharashtra will be addressed through administrative discussions or changes in the regulatory arrangements. Until further clarification emerges, the withdrawal should not be interpreted as proof that the dispute has been fully resolved.


